Support for Scottish independence grows among progressive England

_71502906_union-like-(2)It’s a late but welcome phenomenon: progressive voices in England adding their support for Scottish independence. At the start of the campaign there was only a trickle of interest and engagement. Yet recently more journalists and columnists from England have stated that independence is an opportunity for the whole of Britain. It’s an opportunity for power to be distributed more equally. It’s an opportunity to devolve decision making to the regions of England. It’s an opportunity for Scotland to lead the way with a modern constitutional settlement. On the day of Cameron’s speech there were numerous voices online echoing this sentiment. I even received an email of independence solidarity from Wales! Here’s a few such voices. (If there are any others I’ve missed post them in the comments!)


A group of English writers and campaigners wrote to the Sunday Herald explaining their support for Scottish independence.

They said “we are writing to ask Scotland to ignore a Prime Minister most of us didn’t vote for either, to take this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity and to vote Yes in September.

We don’t see or fear Scottish independence as separation, we look forward to it as a better way of living together.”

This was signed by: Anthony Barnett, Founder of Open Democracy; Elise Benjamin, Lord Major of Oxford 2011-12; Olly Huitson, co-editor of OurKingdom; Niki Seth-Smith, journalist; Jonathon Dawson, Head of Economics at Schumacher College; James Meadway, economist; Dr Stuart White, fellow in politics at Oxford University; Dr Derek Wall, Department of Politics at Goldsmith College and International Coordinator of the Green Party of England and Wales; Jamie Mackay, Warwick University; Sian Berry, former Green Party Candidate for London Major; Symon Hill, writer; Sam Hollick, councillor; Dr Claire El Mouden, Fellow of Nuffield College at Oxford University; Matt Hanley, Manchester Green Party; Dave Boyle, Consultant at Principle Six; Graham Martin, community activist in York; Mads Ryle, environmental justice campaigner; Michael Pymer, Mental Health Project Worker; Guy Aitchison, School of Public Policy at University College London; Louise Hazen, environmental justice campaigner; Dan Hancox, author; Mark Anthony France, trade union activist; Juliette Daigre, anti-poverty campaigner; Mick Hall, writer.

Update II April 27th 2014:

Andrew Marr: Are you pro-independence for Scotland?

Natalie Bennet, Leader of the Green Party in England and Wales: “Very much so. In terms of the broader European Union, we need to respect the principle of subsidiarity. We need a reformed European Union where people take decisions locally.”

Update III

George Murdie, Labour Member of Parliament for Leeds East said “If I were in Scotland I would be voting for an independent Scotland.”

Update IV

Sir Michael Atiyah, scientist and former President of the Royal Society of Edinburgh and London, said that independence is a huge opportunity to create a more peaceful world. He described nuclear weapons as conspicuous, useless, immoral and expensive symbols of Westminster’s hankering for imperial grandeur“.

Update V

Simon Jenkins, Head of the National Trust and Guardian Journalist, said “If the Scottish referendum does indeed force the absurdity of Britain’s nuclear deterrent out into the light of day, it is worth it for that alone. If it were to go further and kill Trident stone dead, it would be thank you, Salmond, thank you, Scotland.”

Update VI

Russell Brand, actor, comedian and writer, said “They don’t have any control over their own policy or economy that have a negative social impact, so why would Scotland stay under UK rule?…The only reason I would endorse Scottish independence is because the more there is devolution, the more power structures break down, the more power will hopefully reach people that matter – us, normal people.

Increasingly it’s clear that what would be best for the Scottish population would be to have independence and autonomy.”



Tariq Ali, British-Pakisani writer and activist, 10th March 2014: “an independent Scotland, a small state, has far more possibilities of real, genuine internationalism.  That means establishing direct links with many countries and peoples in the world.

Anthony Barnett, founder of openDemocracy, 7th February 2014: “Now that Cameron has called on us English to tell the Scots not to leave us and ‘vote’ no it is time for us English say, “please say ‘Yes'”, we will be better together with independence, as yours’ obliges us to seek our place in the world, together with you, naturally. Our joint problem is the Westminster/Whitehall integument of ‘Britain’.”

Billy Bragg, singer and equality campaigner, 7th February 2014: “I’m in favour of Scottish independence because I believe that it is ultimately about accountability, as is socialism. If the Scots leave, we in England will need to make some big constitutional changes. If a new English parliament or regional assemblies are created, they will surely use proportional representation and, as a result, we will have greater choice at the ballot box.”

Johnathan Freedland, Guardian columnist, 7th February 2014: “It’s not that the Scots are leaving Britain – it’s that Britain has left them… So I no longer dismiss the Scottish yearning behind yes. If I were a Scot, I might well be leaning that way myself.”

Ian Martin, comedy writer with Veep and The Thick of It, December 2013: “I really want Scotland to go for it. Those of us who live in the north of England look south and see the same thing. An England effectively shrunk to the Greater London area…Scots, I implore you. Strike out. And at least take some of us with you.”

Sioned, Wales, 7th February 2014: “Hello Michael, Apparently I’m meant to write to you following David Cameron’s speech today and say ‘oh, please don’t go…please…’ …!?! Just a sign to say that other nations are actually supportive…”

The Artist Taxi Driver, youtube political commentator: “Scotland has a chance…run! Run! Run for your lives!…As a small nation you have a chance to be more equal.”

John Harris, author and curator of The Guardian’s ‘Anywhere but Westminster’, 25th November 2013: “if I had a vote in Scotland I would, with a mixture of trepidation and enthusiasm, vote in favour of independence. Hope rather than fear, and all that. But also something much more fundamental: a chance for at least one part of these islands to exit a decayed consensus, and beat a path towards something better.”

George Monbiot, Guardian columnist and author: “I would vote yes in September if I lived here, on the grounds that it presents an opportunity to do something new, and I furiously hope, despite the evidence, that an independent Scottish government will take it.” And on the day of David Cameron’s speech twitter was flooded with messages of support for Scottish independence from across the UK. uktweets22uktweets1uktweets8uktweets11uktweets9uktweets18uktweets17Tweets compiled by Wings Over Scotland.

Michael Gray
National Collective


Print Friendly

About Michael Gray

Michael studies politics at the University of Glasgow. He admires creativity, optimism and education. He desires peace, social justice and good parties.

There are 10 comments

  1. Project Hope Over Fear

    One of the things that is so sad about this campaign is the fact that a so-called progressive newspaper such as the Guardian purports to be, is venomously attacking Scotland’s independence just as much as the rabid UKIP/Tory right newspapers such as the Daily Mail.

    You would think that the Guardian would welcome the opportunity to democratically create a modern nation north of the border that could shine as a beacon of hope and show the way for those disenfranchised progressive voices south of the border, but sadly not in the case of the Guardian that appears to have bought into the neo-liberal Blair/Brown/Miliband opportunist and nae principles Labour party’s hatred of Scotland and the legitimate peaceful aspirations of its people for better government and a better way of life, lock stock and barrel.

  2. Ellie Mayze

    I was in tears at the end of Chunkymark’s rant on Scottish Independence (otherwise known as The Artist Taxi Driver) because his voice broke after telling Scots to ‘Run! Run for your lives!’. I have no compunction to desert my loved ones in England or the rest of the UK, particularly as my family is exactly 50/50 English/Scottish, every marriage, including my own – but I do believe we can put the English people in a more powerful position, to change how their beautiful lands are governed, by leaving and [attempting to] lead by example. Peas n loaf, English, Welsh and Irish people. The responsiblity to support and promote business links between our nations is being taken seriously by us up in Haggisland. And our doors are always going to open to you – with a place at the hearth.

  3. Wyrdtimes

    “It’s an opportunity to devolve decision making to the regions of England”

    Much better than that it’s an opportunity to devolve power to England and then have the English decide how they want to devolve power within England.

  4. th43

    England needs to take a “Yes” vote seriously and begin to prepare for an independent Scotland.

    We need to declare plan for a Bank Holiday, organise street parties, stockpile fireworks and buy shares in Champagne importers

  5. IndependentEngland

    This is all starting to get extremely boring. I will be very glad when the referendum is done and hopefully Scotland will bring 300 years of whinging to an end and declare independence. Is there any serious possibility that they will vote NO? Surely not? What a total loss of face that would bring. To actually admit that they would rather be joined with and dominated by an England that has ten times the population of Scotland than run their own country. If they do vote NO I and many other English people will be both incredulous and extremely pissed off. Let’s hope it doesn’t happen. If it does I suppose somehow we English will get the blame.

    1. Morag Kerr

      Considering how hard Cameron and his cronies are lying in their teeth and threatening the Scots with the plagues of Egypt if they vote Yes, I don’t think you should be terribly surprised if some blame for a No vote gets flung in that direction.

  6. RockHaggis

    EU, NATO , currency Union …. without knowing what you will write into a written constitution … you can only guess at the answers to those questions. An Article that makes any concession of sovereignty subject to rigorous public debate and a referendum … as you can imagine … will have a great impact on which way we proceed! However if you don’t write it in, then who’s to stop those that control the now, controlling the then?

    Now is the time to start that debate, begin that process …….get involved

  7. Ruth Henshaw

    This parochial list of small time “Artists” is meant to be evidence of something apparently. Nevermind the quality just count the numbers.

Post Your Thoughts